
The Short Answer
Most brands that give advice say to take the larger size: Nike, New Balance and Dr. Martens all do. The exceptions are shoes that run large or loosen with wear. Converse says its Chuck Taylors run large, and K2 says to size down in snowboard boots because the liners pack out.
Before you go up half a size, check whether the problem is length at all. If the shoe feels tight across the ball of the foot while your toes have room, a wider fit in your usual size works better than a longer shoe.
What Brands Say When You Are Between Sizes
From the brands’ own size guides:
- Nike: size up when your measurement falls between two sizes. For running shoes, Nike wants about a thumb's width between the big toe and the end of the shoe.
- New Balance: choose the larger size, then fine-tune the fit with socks, insoles or lacing.
- Dr. Martens: most styles run true to size; between sizes, take the larger size with an insole. Dr. Martens makes mostly whole sizes.
- ASICS: add 1 to 1.5 cm to your foot length when you pick a size; for running shoes, you may consider going up half a size.
- Converse: Chuck Taylor All Stars run large, so go half a size down.
- Crocs: most shoes fit roomy; if you normally wear a half size, order a size down. For kids between sizes, round up.
- Blundstone: the boots fit true to size; go half a size up only if you want a wider fit.
- Timberland: some styles run a size larger or smaller, and the product page says so.
- K2 snowboard boots: size down when you are between sizes, because the liners pack out with riding.
As a rule of thumb from this list: where a brand says its shoes run roomy or loosen with wear, it suggests the smaller size. Otherwise it suggests the larger one.
Why You End Up Between Sizes
US sizes move in half sizes of 1/6 inch, about 4.2 mm, and a foot rarely lands exactly on one of them. On the generic chart a men's 9 fits a 26.2 cm foot and a men's 9.5 a 26.7 cm foot, so a 26.4 cm foot sits between the two, a little closer to the 9. Our foot length chart gives the nearest size, the way the ISO conversion standard reads a size: a shoe is expected to fit feet up to half a size either side of its own foot length.
Some brands make the gap bigger: Dr. Martens comes mostly in whole sizes and many UGG styles in whole sizes only, and each Birkenstock EU size covers two US half sizes.
Length or Width? Check Before You Size Up
A bigger size adds length and only a little width. New Balance publishes the foot width each of its widths fits, and the numbers make the point:
- Men's 9 in the standard width (D): fits a foot 10.4 cm wide.
- Men's 9.5 in the standard width (D): 10.5 cm, 1 mm more.
- Men's 9 in the wide width (2E): 10.7 cm, 3 mm more, at the same length.
So if the shoe presses at the sides but your toes have room, try the wide version of your usual size first. If your toes touch the front, you need more length. Our shoe width chart lists which brands offer which widths, and Do You Need Wide Shoes? shows how to tell.
How Much Room the Brands Want
Where brands give a number, it ranges from about ¼ inch (6 mm) to 1.5 cm:
- Nike: about a thumb's width between the big toe and the end of a running shoe.
- ASICS: add 1 to 1.5 cm to your foot length; in running shoes, half to a full thumb's width at the toes.
- Birkenstock: about ¼ inch of space around the foot, according to its US fit guide. Birkenstock Australia adds 10 mm to the foot length.
Will the Shoe Stretch?
Only in width, and only a little. Blundstone says its leather stretches over the instep with wear but never lengthwise. A shoe that feels slightly snug across the top can ease up; a shoe that is too short will not get longer.
A Quick Checklist
Before you order:
- Measure both feet in the evening, standing, and use the longer one. Our guide shows how to measure your feet.
- Look up that length in the chart of the brand you are buying, not in a generic chart. The brand size comparison shows two brands side by side.
- Read the brand's advice: up for most brands, down for Converse, Crocs and snowboard boots.
- If only the width feels tight, try a wide fit before a bigger size.
- Wear the socks you will use, and walk in the shoes before you decide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it better to size up or down in shoes?
Most brands say to size up when you are between sizes: Nike, New Balance and Dr. Martens do. Converse Chuck Taylors run large and Crocs fit roomy, so their advice is to go down instead.
Should I go half a size up for running shoes?
Often, yes. ASICS says you may consider going up half a size in running shoes, and Nike wants about a thumb's width between the big toe and the end of the shoe.
What if a brand only makes whole sizes?
Dr. Martens suggests the larger size with an insole. A retailer copy of UGG's chart says to take the nearest whole size you usually wear.
Do shoes stretch to fit?
In width, a little; in length, no. Blundstone says its leather stretches over the instep with wear but never lengthwise.